Join Us For

The Lenny's Experience

Traditional Coal-Fired Pizza & More!
View the Menu
Lenny's

August

Pizza of the Month
August-26

The Sweet Chili Clucker

Sweet meets savory in every bite with a Thai sweet chili base, crispy chicken, pineapple, tomatoes, and mozzarella, all finished with fresh green onions and sesame seeds for the perfect kick. Available all August. Stop by and see what everyone's talking about before it's gone.

14" Pizza
Our Story

The Lenny's Experience Is
A Joyride For Your Senses

Lenny’s coal fired pizza, brought to you by Costas Restaurant Group, is Valparaiso’s newest and most unique pizza restaurant. Inspired by iconic pizza restaurants in New Haven, Connecticut, Lenny’s brings a taste of the east coast to Valpo. The 70s come back to life in our newly renovated restaurant. We feature tasty wings, pasta and salads in addition to Northwest Indiana’s only coal fired pizza. Come on in and find out why Locals Love Lennys!

Coal-Fired

Signature Pies

All 14″ pizzas are cooked in our coal-fired oven and will have a classic coal charred crust. Upon request, pizzas can be cooked in our deck oven from Tony’s Place.

LENNY'S PIE
$19

House marinara + cupping pepperoni + fresh jalapeño + fresh mozzarella + goat cheese + honey drizzle

MARGHERITA PIE
$17

House marinara + EVOO + fresh mozzarella + fresh basil

HOG HEAVEN
$19

House marinara + mozzarella + bacon + Italian sausage + cupping pepperoni

TRIED & TRUE
$18

House marinara + Italian sausage + roasted mushrooms + green pepper + red onion

THE SMOKESTACK
$19

BBQ sauce + pulled pork + red onion + green onion + ranch drizzle

THE JERK
$18

Jerk sauce + grilled chicken + red onion + fresh jalapeño + pineapple + green onion + ranch & lime juice drizzle

GREEKING OUT!
$20

Oil & garlic + spinach + mozzarella + kalamata olives + red onion + feta + Greek dressing drizzle

CHI-TOWN'S FINEST
$19

House marinara + garlic + Italian beef + Italian sausage + mozzarella + mild giardiniera

Build Your Own

Pizza & Calzones

Pick a base, pick your toppings, and we’ll do the rest. All bases are 14″ and cooked in our coal-fired oven.

RED BASE
$16+

House marinara + mozzarella

WHITE BASE
$17+

EVOO + garlic + Romano + mozzarella + ricotta

CALZONE
$12+

Mozzarella base with a side of house marinara

VEGGIES
$2

mushroom + red onion + green onion + green pepper + jalapeño + spinach + pepperoncini + pineapple + broccoli + cherry tomato + sliced tomato

PREMIUM
$2.50

kalamata olives + giardiniera + fresh basil + fresh mozzarella + Parmesan + goat cheese + feta + romano + house sriracha honey

PROTEINS
$3

pepperoni + Italian sausage + bacon + ham + pulled pork + chicken + Italian beef + meatball

Our Menu

À la Carte

Salads
CAESAR SALAD V
$12/$7

Romaine, house croutons, grated parmesan, black pepper, tossed with Caesar dressing.

HOUSE SALAD V/GF
$10/$6

Iceberg, cherry tomatoes, English cucumbers, Parmesan, choice of dressing.

THE GLENDALE V/GF
$14/$8

Greens, tomatoes, craisins, avocado, almonds, cornbread croutons, roasted red peppers, green onion, goat cheese, balsamic citrus vinaigrette.

GREEK VILLAGE SALAD V/GF
$14/$8

Tomato, English cucumbers, green peppers, kalamata olives, red onion, feta, Greek herb & oil dressing.

ADD CHICKEN - $5

BALSAMIC VINAIGRETTE | RANCH | CAESAR |
CITRUS BALSAMIC | BLUE CHEESE | OIL & VINEGAR

Starters
PESTO BURRATA
$15

Pesto + burrata + arugula + bruschetta mix + balsamic reduction drizzle + crostinis

ROASTED RED PEPPER HUMMUS
$11

Hummus + EVOO + roasted garlic + crostinis + RRP aioli
$3 for fresh veggies

GOAT IN THE GARDEN
$11

Spicy marinara + baked goat cheese + basil chiffonade + house baked pizza bread

PICKLE CHIPS
$13

Hand breaded pickle chips + ranch

MEATBALLS GF
$14

Prime beef + Italian sausage + house marinara + Romano + ricotta + parsley

PANE AL FORNO
$8

House baked pizza bread + EVOO + roasted garlic and herbs + Romano + Parmesan + side marinara

Oven Baked Wings
Wings (8)
$15

CHOICE OF ONE SAUCE OR RUB
DRY RUBS: lemon pepper, nashville hot, honey garlic
SAUCES: garlic parm, bbq, honey sriracha, buffalo, mango habanero

Desserts
STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE
$10

House-made pound cake + macerated strawberries + Cool Whip

LEMON TORTE
$12

Lemon custard + buttery shortcrust pastry + crushed almonds and pine nuts + powder sugar dusting

TIRAMISU
$12

Espresso soaked ladyfingers + mascarpone filling + cocoa powder

Handhelds
LENNY'S SMASH BURGER
$17

Two smashed prime patties + caramelized onions + tamed jalapeño + American + lettuce + tomato + Lenny’s sauce + potato bun

CAROLINA HOOSIER
$17

Giant pork tenderloin + dill pickles + carolina mustard + potato bun

MOM'S ITALIAN BEEF
$17

House Italian beef + mozzarella + mild giardiniera + au jus + French baguette

MEATBALL SUB
$16

House meatballs + house marinara + mozzarella + pepperoncini + parsley + hoagie roll

BBQ PULLED PORK SANDO
$17

Pulled pork + Sriracha BBQ sauce + house coleslaw + pickles + potato bun

Noodles
COALHOUSE MAC
$18

Cavatappi + cajun cheese sauce + Andoullie sausage

SMOKEHOUSE FETTUCCINI
$17

Fettuccini + house gouda alfredo + cherry tomatoes + chicken + bacon + green pepper

SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS
$16

House marinara + thin spaghetti noodles + house meatballs + basil chiffonade

Calzones
AFTER MIDNIGHT
$16

Italian sausage + caramelized onions + ricotta + mozzarella

THE BURNOUT
$16

Buffalo chicken + mozzarella + cheddar + green onion + ranch

BROCC & ROLL
$16

Broccoli & cheddar bechamel + ham + broccoli + mozzarella + cracked black pepper + oyster crackers

MAMA MIA!
$16

House meatballs + mozzarella + ricotta + Parmesan + fresh basil

drinks
coke products
$3.95
SPARKLING WATER
$3.75
FRESH BREWED ICED TEA
$3.95
LEMONADE
$3.50
View Full Menu
Order Takeout
Order Delivery
Close
© 2026 Lenny's Coal-Fired Pizza | JWM Marketing & Web Design
3800 N Calumet Ave, Valparaiso, IN 46383
(219) 312-7882
Close